From New Rules & Decisions week of November 26, 2012.
Davis v. Edwards Oil Co. of Lawrenceburg, Inc., 2012 WL 5954139 (N.D. Ala. November 28, 2012). Free copy available here.
Hours of service requirements present motor carrier risks from two threat vectors: (1) regulatory (FMCSA HOS rule), and (2) tort litigation.
The years-long battle between FMCSA and litigants in various federal courts of appeals over the hours of service regulations manifest one obvious source of risk to motor carriers in regard to driver’s hours.
Litigation on this represents a threat from the same activity and management issue – driver’s hours – but one that comes from a distinct direction.
Ed Regan of Tranzact Technologies made this point recently in his “Two Minute Warning” series, noting motor carrier management estimating loss of productivity percentage to the extent of 7 to 9 percent. Click for video blog box on this page.
Legal and business factors combine to present three-fold constraint for management:
1. Regulatory – FMCSA enforcement of HOS rule;
2. Litigation – Tort lawsuit based on violation of HOS limits as negligence per se – with respondeat superior or other vicarious liability exposure for motor carrier; and
3. Productivity pressures from reduced available driver hours.